Skip to content 
What is the difference between tinplate and tin free steel?
difference between tinplate and tin free steel, ETP (Electrolytic Tin Sheet) is cold rolled steel sheet coated with tin for good corrosion resistance. This is used primarily for 3 pieces welded cans. TFS (Tin Free Steel) is cold rolled steel which has been Electro-plated with a chrome / chromium oxide finish.
Tinplate and tin free steel are two common materials used in the packaging industry, particularly for food and beverage containers. While both materials serve the purpose of preventing corrosion and providing a protective barrier against external elements, there are key differences between the two that impact their use and applications.
What is Tinplate and Tin Free Steel?
Firstly, tinplate is a type of steel plate coated with a thin layer of tin. This coating provides a highly effective barrier against corrosion and oxidation, making tinplate an ideal material for food and beverage cans. Tinplate is also known for its aesthetic appeal, as the shiny surface of the tin coating enhances the visual appearance of the packaging. On the other hand, tin free steel, as the name suggests, does not have a tin coating. Instead, tin free steel is coated with other materials such as polymer or lacquer to provide protection against corrosion.
The difference between Tinplate and Tin Free Steel
Tinplate and TFS (Tin Free Steel) are two types of materials used in the manufacture of metal containers, such as cans and lids. Both materials have different properties and characteristics that make them suitable for various applications. Here are the main differences between tinplate and tin free steel:
1. Composition:
Tinplate is a steel sheet coated with a thin layer of tin. Tin provides corrosion protection and improves the solderability of the material. TFS, on the other hand, is a tin-free steel and instead has a mixed coating composed of chromium and chromium oxide.
2. Corrosion resistance:
Tinplate has excellent corrosion resistance due to the tin coating, while TFS, while also offering corrosion resistance, may be slightly inferior compared to tinplate due to its chromium and chromium oxide coating.
3. Weldability:
Tinplate is suitable for electric welding, which facilitates its use in the manufacture of packaging. However, TFS is not suitable for electric welding, which limits its use in certain applications, such as caps and stuffing boxes.
4. Manufacturing process:
The tinplate manufacturing process involves the application of a tin layer by electroplating and a passivation film. TFS, on the other hand, is manufactured by applying a mixed chromium and chromium oxide coating.
5. Origin:
TFS emerged as an alternative to tinplate in response to the rising price of tin and the danger of depletion of tin supplies. TFS is a material capable of replacing tinplate in many applications, as it has similar properties.
6. Cost
One of the main differences between tinplate and tin free steel is their cost. Tinplate is generally more expensive than tin free steel due to the higher cost of tin as a raw material. This cost difference can impact the overall production cost of packaging materials and may influence manufacturers’ decisions on which material to use. While tinplate offers superior corrosion resistance and aesthetic appeal, some manufacturers may opt for tin free steel to reduce production costs.
7. Recyclability
Another key difference between tinplate and tin free steel is their recyclability. Tinplate is easily recyclable through existing recycling systems, as the tin coating can be easily separated from the steel base. This makes tinplate an environmentally-friendly option for packaging materials. On the other hand, tin free steel is more challenging to recycle due to the presence of other coatings such as polymer or lacquer. This can impact the sustainability of packaging materials made from tin free steel, as the recycling process may be more complex and less efficient.
8. Performance
In terms of performance, tinplate offers superior protection against corrosion compared to tin free steel. The tin coating creates a strong barrier that prevents rust and oxidation, extending the shelf life of products stored in tinplate containers. Tin free steel, while still providing some level of protection against corrosion, may not be as effective as tinplate in harsh environments or prolonged storage conditions. As a result, manufacturers may choose tinplate for products that require long-term protection against corrosion.
In conclusion, tinplate and tin-free steel (TFS) are both widely used materials in the packaging industry, each with unique characteristics and applications. Tinplate is known for its excellent corrosion resistance and attractive appearance, making it ideal for applications where durability and visual appeal are important. However, it tends to be more expensive than TFS. On the other hand, TFS offers a more cost-effective solution but may not provide the same level of corrosion protection as tinplate.
Both materials share similar mechanical properties and corrosion resistance, yet they differ in composition, weldability, and manufacturing processes. The decision to use tinplate or TFS depends on factors such as cost, recyclability, and specific performance requirements. By understanding these differences, manufacturers can choose the material that best aligns with their packaging needs and production criteria.
Tinplate and TFS are similar materials in terms of mechanical properties and corrosion resistance, but differ in their composition, weldability and manufacturing process. The choice between tinplate and TFS will depend on the specific application needs and manufacturing requirements.
What is tinplate used for?
Tinplate is used for making all types of containers such as food cans, beverage cans, 18-liter cans, and artistic cans. Its applications are not limited to containers; recently, tinplate has also been used for making electrical machinery parts and many other products. also Tinplate serves various industries, including food and beverage, electronics, automotive, and construction.
Is tinplate food safe?
Food cans are made of tinplate or Tin free Steel coating on steel sheet and are safe materials. There is no harm to eating out of the can, if the can was harmful it would have already contaminated the food.
